ACV vs Replacement Cost Calculator

After a fire, storm or water loss, insurers often pay the actual cash value (ACV) first and hold back depreciation until repairs are done. List damaged items or building components to estimate depreciation, your first payment after the deductible, and how much more you can recover with a replacement cost policy.

First payment (ACV less deductible)-
Replacement cost (RCV)-
Total depreciation-
Actual cash value (ACV)-
Recoverable after repairs-
Total if fully recovered-

Estimates only. Results depend on the inputs you provide and are not a loan offer, appraisal, tax bill or claim determination.

ACV, RCV and depreciation

Replacement cost value (RCV) is what it costs to repair or replace with like kind and quality today. Depreciation reflects age and condition. Actual cash value is RCV minus depreciation. Straight-line depreciation divides age by expected useful life - a 10-year-old roof with a 25-year life is depreciated about 40%.

Recoverable depreciation

Under a replacement cost policy, depreciation withheld from the first payment is usually "recoverable": you get it once you complete repairs or replacement and submit proof, typically within a deadline set by the policy. Policies with ACV-only coverage (common for older roofs in Texas) do not pay it back.

Frequently asked questions

Can an insurer depreciate labor?

It depends on the policy language and state rules, and it is a common point of dispute. Read the loss settlement section of your policy and ask the adjuster to show how labor was treated in the estimate.

What useful life should I use?

Common estimates: asphalt shingle roofs 20-30 years, carpet 8-10 years, interior paint 5-10 years, HVAC 15-20 years, water heaters 10-15 years, appliances 10-15 years, electronics 4-7 years. Insurers use their own tables, which you can request.

What if I disagree with the depreciation?

Ask for the estimate in writing with line-item depreciation, provide evidence of the item's age and condition (receipts, photos, maintenance records), and request a re-inspection. Many policies include an appraisal clause, and Texas policyholders can file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance.

Related guides

Make your next move with confidence

Run the numbers before you buy, sell, refinance or file a claim. Every calculator is free, private and runs right in your browser.

Browse free tools